--- title: "Caledonian Hotel vs Dumfries Villa: which hotel is better?" description: "Pick Dumfries Villa. It leads in 2 of 3 categories. Caledonian Hotel or Dumfries Villa in Dumfries? Compare guest ratings, location, amenities, rooms and…" url: https://stayversus.com/en/compare/caledonian-hotel-dumfries-vs-dumfries-villa-dumfries/ language: en source: StayVersus (https://stayversus.com) retrieved: 2026-10-15 --- # Caledonian Hotel vs Dumfries Villa Both are in Dumfries, 660 m apart. Here is where each one is stronger. Hotel · ★★★ · Loreburn ## [Caledonian Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/caledonian-hotel-dumfries/) - **Guest rating:** 8.9 · Excellent - **Location score:** 6.0 - **Score by category:** 0 of 3 [Check rates](https://stayversus.com/go/1238590/agoda/?lang=en) Guesthouse · ★★★ · Town Centre ## [Dumfries Villa](https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/dumfries-villa-dumfries/) - **Guest rating:** 8.9 · Excellent - **Location score:** 7.7 - **Score by category:** 2 of 3 [Check rates](https://stayversus.com/go/1369447/agoda/?lang=en) The short answer ## Pick Dumfries Villa It leads in 2 of 3 categories. 660 m apart. ### Choose Dumfries Villa if you want - more restaurants on the doorstep ### Why is Caledonian Hotel better than Dumfries Villa? 1. Later check-out (11:00 vs 10:00) (+1h) ### Why is Dumfries Villa better than Caledonian Hotel? 1. 370 m closer to public transport (−370 m) 2. 39 more restaurants and cafés within 500 m (+39) 3. More walkable surroundings (walk grade 67 vs 47) (+20) ## All compared facts Every category is scored from 0 to 10 with the same formula for every hotel. | | Caledonian Hotel | Dumfries Villa | | --- | --- | --- | | Score by category | | Guest rating | 8.9 | 8.9 | | Location | 6.0 | 7.7 (+1.7) | | Public transport | 7.9 | 9.9 (+2.0) | | Ratings & reviews | | StayVersus score | 8.9 | 8.9 | | Guest rating | 8.9 | 8.9 | | Number of reviews | 24 (+11) | 13 | | Google rating | 4.1/5 | 4.7/5 (+0.6) | | Google reviews | 355 (+229) | 126 | | Rank in Dumfries | top 50% | top 50% | | Location | | Location score | 6.0 | 7.7 (+1.7) | | Distance to the centre | 380 m | 290 m | | To public transport | 540 m | 170 m (−370 m) | | To the airport | 79 km | 78 km | | Restaurants within 500 m | 14 | 53 (+39) | | Sights within 1 km | 2 | 3 | | Rooms & building | | Star rating | ★★★ | ★★★ | | Listed amenities | 4 | 5 | | Policies | | Check-in from | 15:30 | 15:00 (−1h) | | Check-out until | 11:00 (+1h) | 10:00 | | Amenities | | Free Wi-Fi | ✓ | ✓ | | Free parking | ✓ | – | | Free breakfast | ✓ | ✓ | | Which hotel suits you | | Families with children | ✓ | ✓ | | Couples | – | ✓ | | Sightseeing on foot | – | ✓ | | Business trips | – | ✓ | | Spa & relaxation | ✓ | ✓ | [Swap sides](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/dumfries-villa-dumfries-vs-caledonian-hotel-dumfries/) ## Location 660 m apart ## Caledonian Hotel or Dumfries Villa: common questions ### Which is better, Caledonian Hotel or Dumfries Villa? Dumfries Villa leads in 2 of 3 categories, including location, public transport. ### Which is cheaper, Caledonian Hotel or Dumfries Villa? Prices change by date. Pick your dates above to see both nightly prices side by side. ### How far apart are Caledonian Hotel and Dumfries Villa? The two hotels are 660 m apart in a straight line. ## More match-ups - [Caledonian Hotel vs The Hill Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/caledonian-hotel-dumfries-vs-the-hill-hotel-dumfries/) - [Caledonian Hotel vs Hamilton House](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/caledonian-hotel-dumfries-vs-hamilton-house-dumfries/) - [Caledonian Hotel vs The Cairndale Hotel & Leisure Club](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/caledonian-hotel-dumfries-vs-the-cairndale-hotel-leisure-club-dumfries/) - [Dumfries Villa vs The Cairndale Hotel & Leisure Club](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/dumfries-villa-dumfries-vs-the-cairndale-hotel-leisure-club-dumfries/) - [Dumfries Villa vs The Hill Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/dumfries-villa-dumfries-vs-the-hill-hotel-dumfries/) - [Dumfries Villa vs Hamilton House](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/dumfries-villa-dumfries-vs-hamilton-house-dumfries/) - [Dumfries Villa vs White Hart Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/dumfries-villa-dumfries-vs-white-hart-hotel-dumfries/) ## Compare now Updated 6 Oct 2026. Data: Agoda, Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap, OurAirports and hotels' own websites. We may earn a commission from partner links; it never changes the comparison. [How we score](https://stayversus.com/en/about/) --- Source: https://stayversus.com/en/compare/caledonian-hotel-dumfries-vs-dumfries-villa-dumfries/. Facts are compiled by StayVersus from partner data (Agoda), Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap, OurAirports, public Google Maps listings and hotels' own websites. Scores use one formula for every hotel. Methodology: https://stayversus.com/en/about/