---
title: "Malmaison Edinburgh vs Smith Place Hotel | StayVersus"
description: "Pick Malmaison Edinburgh. It leads in 3 of 4 categories. Malmaison Edinburgh or Smith Place Hotel in Edinburgh? Compare guest ratings, location, amenities…"
url: https://stayversus.com/en/compare/malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh-vs-smith-place-hotel-edinburgh/
language: en
source: StayVersus (https://stayversus.com)
retrieved: 2026-10-14
---

# Malmaison Edinburgh vs Smith Place Hotel

Both are in Edinburgh, 1.2 km apart. Here is where each one is stronger.

Hotel · ★★★★ · Leith Harbour & Newhaven
## [Malmaison Edinburgh](https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh/)

- **Guest rating:** 8.6 ·  Very good

- **Location score:** 7.3

- **Score by category:** 3 of 4

[Check rates](https://stayversus.com/go/1816576/agoda/?lang=en)

Hotel · ★★★ · Leith Central
## [Smith Place Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/smith-place-hotel-edinburgh/)

- **Guest rating:** 7.7 ·  Good

- **Location score:** 7.3

- **Score by category:** 0 of 4

[Check rates](https://stayversus.com/go/2111256/agoda/?lang=en)

The short answer

## Pick Malmaison Edinburgh

It leads in 3 of 4 categories. 1.2 km apart.

### Choose Malmaison Edinburgh if you want

-   the more consistently praised stay
-   to be closer to the beach
-   a big hotel with more facilities

### Choose Smith Place Hotel if you want

-   to walk to the sights
-   a smaller, quieter hotel

### Why is Malmaison Edinburgh better than Smith Place Hotel?

1.  Higher guest rating (8.6 vs 7.7) (+0.9)
2.  930 m closer to the beach (770 m vs 1.7 km) (−930 m)
3.  Higher star rating (4★ vs 3★) (+1★)
4.  More guest reviews (290 vs 36), so the rating is more reliable (×8.1)
5.  A larger hotel with more facilities (100 vs 9 rooms) (×11.1)

### Why is Smith Place Hotel better than Malmaison Edinburgh?

1.  1.2 km closer to the city centre (−1.2 km)
2.  Earlier check-in (14:00 vs 15:00) (−1h)
3.  A smaller, more intimate hotel (9 vs 100 rooms) (−91)

## All compared facts

Every category is scored from 0 to 10 with the same formula for every hotel.

 

|  | Malmaison Edinburgh | Smith Place Hotel |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Score by category |
| Guest rating | 8.6  (+0.9) | 7.7 |
| Location | 7.3 | 7.3 |
| Facilities | 5.0 | – |
| Families | 0.0 | – |
| Spa & wellness | 1.5 | – |
| Beach access | 7.7  (+3.2) | 4.5 |
| Public transport | 9.6  (+0.8) | 8.8 |
| Ratings & reviews |
| StayVersus score | 8.6  (+0.5) | 8.1 |
| Guest rating | 8.6  (+0.9) | 7.7 |
| Number of reviews | 290  (+254) | 36 |
| Google rating | – | 3.9/5 |
| Google reviews | – | 97 |
| Rank in Edinburgh | top 46%  (+38%) | top 84% |
| Location |
| Location score | 7.3 | 7.3 |
| Distance to the centre | 3.5 km | 2.3 km  (−1.2 km) |
| To the beach | 770 m  (−930 m) | 1.7 km |
| To public transport | 230 m  (−130 m) | 360 m |
| To the airport | 13 km | 13 km |
| Restaurants within 500 m | 85 | 103  (+18) |
| Sights within 1 km | 6  (+2) | 4 |
| Rooms & building |
| Star rating | ★★★★  (+1★) | ★★★ |
| Rooms | 100 | 9 |
| Floors | – | 1 |
| Newest building or renovation | – | 2020 |
| Listed amenities | 14  (+10) | 4 |
| Policies |
| Check-in from | 15:00 | 14:00  (−1h) |
| Check-out until | 11:00 | 11:00 |
| Amenities |
| Free Wi-Fi | ✓ | ✓ |
| Free parking | ✓ | ✓ |
| Laundry | ✓ | – |
| Luggage storage | ✓ | – |
| Breakfast | ✓ | – |
| Bar | ✓ | – |
| 24-hour room service | ✓ | – |
| Gym | ✓ | – |
| Smoke-free | ✓ | – |
| Air conditioning | ✓ | – |
| Coffee or tea maker | ✓ | ✓ |
| Which hotel suits you |
| Families with children | ✓ | – |
| Couples | ✓ | – |
| Beach holidays | ✓ | – |
| Sightseeing on foot | ✓ | ✓ |
| Business trips | ✓ | – |
| Spa & relaxation | ✓ | – |

[Swap sides](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/smith-place-hotel-edinburgh-vs-malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh/)

## Location

1.2 km apart

## Malmaison Edinburgh or Smith Place Hotel: common questions

### Which is better, Malmaison Edinburgh or Smith Place Hotel?

Malmaison Edinburgh leads in 3 of 4 categories, including guest rating, beach access, public transport.

### Which is cheaper, Malmaison Edinburgh or Smith Place Hotel?

Prices change by date. Pick your dates above to see both nightly prices side by side.

### Which hotel is closer to the centre?

Smith Place Hotel is closer: 2.3 km from the centre, against 3.5 km for Malmaison Edinburgh.

### Which hotel is closer to the beach?

Malmaison Edinburgh is 770 m from the nearest beach; Smith Place Hotel is 1.7 km.

### How far apart are Malmaison Edinburgh and Smith Place Hotel?

The two hotels are 1.2 km apart in a straight line.

## More match-ups

-   [Malmaison Edinburgh vs Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh - Leith Waterfront By IHG](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/holiday-inn-express-edinburgh-leith-waterfront-by-ihg-edinburgh-vs-malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh/)
-   [Malmaison Edinburgh vs The Adelphi Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh-vs-the-adelphi-hotel-edinburgh/)
-   [Malmaison Edinburgh vs Mackenzie Guest House](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/mackenzie-guest-house-edinburgh-vs-malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh/)
-   [Malmaison Edinburgh vs Park View House Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh-vs-park-view-house-hotel-edinburgh/)
-   [Smith Place Hotel vs 233 Leith apartment](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/233-leith-apartment-edinburgh-vs-smith-place-hotel-edinburgh/)
-   [Smith Place Hotel vs Leith House Hotel](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/leith-house-hotel-edinburgh-vs-smith-place-hotel-edinburgh/)
-   [Smith Place Hotel vs Cambridge House](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/cambridge-house-edinburgh-vs-smith-place-hotel-edinburgh/)
-   [Smith Place Hotel vs Antler Guest House](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/antler-guest-house-edinburgh-vs-smith-place-hotel-edinburgh/)

## Compare now

Updated 6 Oct 2026. Data: Agoda, Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap, OurAirports and hotels' own websites. We may earn a commission from partner links; it never changes the comparison. [How we score](https://stayversus.com/en/about/)

---
Source: https://stayversus.com/en/compare/malmaison-edinburgh-edinburgh-vs-smith-place-hotel-edinburgh/. Facts are compiled by StayVersus from partner data (Agoda), Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap, OurAirports, public Google Maps listings and hotels' own websites. Scores use one formula for every hotel. Methodology: https://stayversus.com/en/about/