---
title: "Bonefish Bay Motel, Marathon (FL) | StayVersus"
description: "Bonefish Bay Motel in Marathon (FL): rated 9.0 by guests, 2.5-star. Amenities, location and nearby alternatives compared side by side."
url: https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/bonefish-bay-motel-marathon-fl/
language: en
source: StayVersus (https://stayversus.com)
retrieved: 2026-10-14
---

Motel · ★★★
# Bonefish Bay Motel

Key Colony Beach, Marathon (FL), United States

9.0 ·  Excellent 31 reviews ·  #2 #2 of 12 in Marathon (FL) ·  4.3/5 on Google, 320 reviews ·  2.9 Location score
## About Bonefish Bay Motel

Bonefish Bay Motel is a motel in Key Colony Beach, Marathon (FL), United States. It holds a 2.5-star rating. Guests rate it 9.0 out of 10 across 31 reviews. Facilities include swimming pool, free parking, free wi-fi. It is 4.4 km from the centre of Marathon (FL). The nearest beach is 1.5 km away. The nearest airport, Key West International Airport (EYW), is 77 km away.

- **Type:** Motel

- **Star rating:** ★★★

- **Check-in from:** 15:00

- **Rooms:** 8

- **Floors:** 2

- **Opened:** 2017

- **Other stays within 500 m:** 3

12565 Overseas Highway [bonefishbayresort.com](https://bonefishbayresort.com/)

## How Bonefish Bay Motel scores

Better rated than 70% of hotels in Marathon (FL)

-   Guest rating **9.0**
-   Location **2.9**
-   Beach access **5.2**

Marathon (FL) average

## Rating on Google

4.3/5

320 Google reviews

-   5★56%
-   4★17%
-   3★10%
-   2★5%
-   1★12%

From the property’s public Google Maps listing. It is shown for reference and is not part of the StayVersus score.

## Amenities

Swimming poolFree parkingFree Wi-Fi

### Pool & wellness

-   Swimming pool

### Internet

-   Free Wi-Fi

### Parking & transport

-   Free parking

### In the rooms

-   Air conditioning

Based on the property listing at our booking partner.

## Location

- **Location score:** **2.9**/10

- **Walk grade:** **31**/100 Car recommended

- **Restaurants & cafés within 500 m:** **5**

- **Sights within 1 km:** **1**

<table class="dist" data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><tbody data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><tr data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><th scope="row" data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">Nearest beach<span data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""></span></th><td class="num" data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><b data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">1.5 km</b><span data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">24 min walk</span></td></tr><tr data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><th scope="row" data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">Nearest airport<span data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">Key West International Airport (EYW)</span></th><td class="num" data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><b data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">77 km</b><span data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">174 min drive</span></td></tr><tr data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><th scope="row" data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">Distance to the centre<span data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">Marathon (FL)</span></th><td class="num" data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7=""><b data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">4.4 km</b><span data-astro-cid-s3y4nmt7="">10 min drive</span></td></tr></tbody></table>

### Sights nearby

-   Florida Keys Aquarium Encounters950 m

## Bonefish Bay Motel: in detail

Bonefish Bay Motel offers top-notch services and amenities, ensuring guests experience utmost comfort. Maintain seamless communication using the complimentary Wi-Fi at motel. For visitors traveling by automobile, complimentary parking is available. For extended visits or whenever required, the laundromat ensures your preferred travel garments remain fresh and accessible. At the motel, discerning guests can also enjoy on-site culinary facilities like BBQ facilities tailored to their preferences. Bonefish Bay Motel provides a superb assortment of leisure amenities for guests to enjoy. Be sure to drop by the pool at motel at least once during your stay.

### Compare

## Compare Bonefish Bay Motel with nearby hotels

Similar hotels within 3 km. Open a match-up to see where each one wins.

-   [Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Marathon Florida Keys](https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/fairfield-by-marriott-inn-suites-marathon-florida-keys-marathon-fl/) Hotel ★★★ 260 m away
    
    8.3 ·  [Compare](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/bonefish-bay-motel-marathon-fl-vs-fairfield-by-marriott-inn-suites-marathon-florida-keys-marathon-fl/)
-   [Hampton Inn Marathon - Florida Keys](https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/hampton-inn-marathon-florida-keys-marathon-fl/) Hotel ★★★ 490 m away
    
    8.9 ·  [Compare](https://stayversus.com/en/compare/bonefish-bay-motel-marathon-fl-vs-hampton-inn-marathon-florida-keys-marathon-fl/)

## Questions about Bonefish Bay Motel

### How do guests rate Bonefish Bay Motel?

Bonefish Bay Motel has a guest rating of 9.0 out of 10 from 31 reviews, which is better than 70% of rated hotels in Marathon (FL).

### Does Bonefish Bay Motel have a pool?

Yes, Bonefish Bay Motel has a swimming pool.

### Is there parking at Bonefish Bay Motel?

Yes, the listing mentions free parking.

### How far is Bonefish Bay Motel from the airport?

The nearest airport, Key West International Airport (EYW), is 77 km away in a straight line.

### Is Bonefish Bay Motel close to the beach?

The nearest beach is 1.5 km from the hotel.

### How many rooms does Bonefish Bay Motel have?

Bonefish Bay Motel has 8 rooms on 2 floors.

Updated 6 Oct 2026. Data: Agoda, Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap, OurAirports and hotels' own websites. We may earn a commission from partner links; it never changes the comparison. [How we score](https://stayversus.com/en/about/)

---
Source: https://stayversus.com/en/hotel/bonefish-bay-motel-marathon-fl/. Facts are compiled by StayVersus from partner data (Agoda), Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap, OurAirports, public Google Maps listings and hotels' own websites. Scores use one formula for every hotel. Methodology: https://stayversus.com/en/about/