Fisher's Hotel vs McKays Hotel
Both are in Pitlochry, 180 m apart. Here is where each one is stronger.
Hotel★★★Pitlochry
Fisher's Hotel
- Guest rating
- 8.5 Very good
- Location score
- 6.3
- Score by category
- 0 of 3
Hotel★★★Pitlochry
McKays Hotel
- Guest rating
- 9.0 Excellent
- Location score
- 6.1
- Score by category
- 1 of 3
The short answer
Too close to call
Neither hotel has a clear edge on the facts we have. Your priorities decide. 180 m apart.
Choose Fisher's Hotel if you want
- a big hotel with more facilities (Rooms: 130 / 7)
Choose McKays Hotel if you want
- the more consistently praised stay (9.0 / 8.5)
- free parking
- a smaller, quieter hotel (Rooms: 7 / 130)
Why is Fisher's Hotel better than McKays Hotel?
- 1More guest reviews (127 vs 19), so the rating is more reliable×6.7
- 2A larger hotel with more facilities (130 vs 7 rooms)×18.6
Why is McKays Hotel better than Fisher's Hotel?
- 1Higher guest rating (9.0 vs 8.5)+0.5
- 2Has free parking
- 3Allows pets
- 4Has an on-site restaurant
- 5Earlier check-in (15:00 vs 16:00)−1h
- 6A smaller, more intimate hotel (7 vs 130 rooms)−123
All compared facts
Every category is scored from 0 to 10 with the same formula for every hotel.
| Fisher's Hotel vs McKays Hotel: which hotel is better? | Fisher's Hotel | McKays Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Score by category | ||
| Guest rating | 8.5 | 9.0 +0.5 |
| Location | 6.3 | 6.1 |
| Facilities | 5.0 | – |
| Spa & wellness | 1.5 | – |
| Public transport | 10.0 | 9.8 |
| Ratings & reviews | ||
| StayVersus score | 8.6 | 9.1 +0.5 |
| Guest rating | 8.5 | 9.0 +0.5 |
| Number of reviews | 127 +108 | 19 |
| Rank in Pitlochry | bottom 7% | bottom 36% +29% |
| Location | ||
| Location score | 6.3 +0.2 | 6.1 |
| Distance to Pitlochry centre | 70 m | 120 m |
| To public transport | 80 m −110 m | 190 m |
| To the airport | 87 km | 87 km |
| Restaurants within 500 m | 25 | 25 |
| To the nearest food shop | 460 m −180 m | 640 m |
| Shops within 500 m | 3 | 2 |
| Sights within 1 km | 0 | 0 |
| Rooms & building | ||
| Star rating | ★★★ | ★★★ |
| Rooms | 130 | 7 |
| Newest building or renovation | 2012 | – |
| Listed amenities | 18 +7 | 11 |
| Policies | ||
| Check-in from | 16:00 | 15:00 −1h |
| Check-out until | 11:00 | 11:00 |
| Amenities | ||
| Free Wi-Fi | ✓ | ✓ |
| EV charging | ✓ | – |
| Shuttle | ✓ | – |
| Concierge | ✓ | – |
| Laundry | ✓ | – |
| Luggage storage | ✓ | ✓ |
| Breakfast | ✓ | ✓ |
| Bar | ✓ | ✓ |
| 24-hour room service | ✓ | – |
| Swimming pool | ✓ | – |
| Wheelchair accessible | ✓ | – |
| Smoke-free | ✓ | ✓ |
| In-room safe | ✓ | – |
| Coffee or tea maker | ✓ | ✓ |
| Blackout curtains | ✓ | – |
| Free parking | – | ✓ |
| Restaurant | – | ✓ |
| Pets allowed | – | ✓ |
| Which hotel suits you | ||
| Spa & relaxation | ✓ | – |
Price for your dates
Prices come from booking partners and can change. The final price is shown before you book.
Live prices around both hotels
Real nightly rates from booking partners for the dates you picked above. Tap a price for the offer.
Nightly price by month
Fisher's HotelMcKays Hotel
- Fisher's Hotel is cheaper in 5 of 9 months
- Fisher's Hotel: €157 a night on average · McKays Hotel: €168 a night on average
Pick a month to check today's price for its cheapest date.
All months
| Month | Fisher's Hotel | McKays Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| December | €142 | €171 |
| January | €151 | €156 |
| February | €160 | €159 |
| March | €160 | €156 |
| April | €172 | €161 |
| May | €200 | €197 |
| June | €162 | – |
| July | €164 | €176 |
| August | €191 | – |
| September | €163 | €176 |
| October | €152 | – |
| November | €98 | €160 |
Averages of real one-night prices for two adults on Agoda, a Tuesday and a Saturday in each month, last checked 13 November 2026. In euros; the final price is shown before you book.
Location
180 m apart
Fisher's Hotel: city centre: 270 m, nearest station Pitlochry: 80 m, Edinburgh Airport (EDI): 87 km, 25 places to eat within 500 m.
McKays Hotel: city centre: 420 m, nearest station Pitlochry: 190 m, Edinburgh Airport (EDI): 87 km, 25 places to eat within 500 m.
Weather in Pitlochry
Fisher's Hotel or McKays Hotel: common questions
Which is better, Fisher's Hotel or McKays Hotel?
McKays Hotel leads in 1 of 3 categories, including guest rating.
Which is cheaper, Fisher's Hotel or McKays Hotel?
Over the year Fisher's Hotel costs about €157 a night on average against €168 at McKays Hotel, and it is cheaper in 5 of the 9 months we checked. Pick your dates above for today's prices.
How far apart are Fisher's Hotel and McKays Hotel?
The two hotels are 180 m apart in a straight line.
Compare now
Updated 6 Oct 2026. Data: Agoda, Overture Maps, OpenStreetMap, OurAirports and hotels' own websites. We may earn a commission from partner links; it never changes the comparison. How we score