Where to stay in Montauk (NY)
Montauk (NY) has 33 places to stay in our index. 7 have enough guest reviews to rank. The average guest rating is 8.5.
- places to stay
- 33
- ranked by guests
- 7
- average rating
- 8.5
- 5-star hotels
- 4
Good to know about hotels in Montauk (NY)
- Best-rated hotel
- Montauk Yacht Club
- Area with most hotels
- Montauk
- Average guest rating
- 8.5
- Hotels with a pool
- 5
- Average walk grade
- 44/100
- 5-star hotels
- 4
Areas of Montauk (NY)
Where the hotels are and how guests rate them.
All hotels in Montauk (NY)
Ranked by StayVersus score: guest rating adjusted for the number of reviews.
Popular match-ups in Montauk (NY)
FAQ: Montauk (NY)
What is the best-rated hotel in Montauk (NY)?
By StayVersus score, Montauk Yacht Club is the best-rated hotel in Montauk (NY), with a guest rating of 9.2 from 55 reviews.
Which area of Montauk (NY) has the most hotels?
Montauk has the most, with 4 rated places to stay.
How many 5-star hotels are there in Montauk (NY)?
We list 4 5-star hotels in Montauk (NY).