Beach hotels in Montauk (NY)

We ranked 6 places to stay in Montauk (NY) that match this list by the StayVersus score. Every hotel can be compared head to head.

Ranked by StayVersus score: guest rating adjusted for the number of reviews.

Resort ★★★★★ Montauk Station

9.2 Excellent 55 reviews 4.2 km

Compare

Hotel ★★★★ Montauk

9.5 Exceptional 5 reviews 750 m

Compare

Hotel ★★★★ Montauk

9.7 Exceptional 3 reviews 500 m

Compare

Hotel ★★★★★ Montauk

10.0 Exceptional 2 reviews 330 m

Compare

Resort ★★★★ Napeague

8.8 Excellent 2 reviews 7.7 km

Compare

Resort ★★★ Montauk

8.1 Very good 18 reviews 320 m

Compare

Popular match-ups in Montauk (NY)